October 20, 2025
AMDG
(Sorry for the crazy formatting problem. I've had a devil of a time writing this and after all was said and done this formatting issue occurred. I went through and corrected it by hand and then the site crashed before I could save all the changes - they had to be made in the editor, not in notepad first which is my custom. I just gave up for now; will try to come back and fix it later.)
I promised yesterday to round out our story about the
Battle of Yorktown and so I am keeping that
promise. Fate seems determined to keep me from doing
so; I had a long text written and it all deleted
again, for perhaps the fourth time now! This is my
last attempt and I'm going to save the text every step
of the way so I get it done.
While Yorktown largely ended the war (it didn't end it
completely all at once but the Bitish people soured on
the war after Yorktown and Parliament decided to make
peace, probably believing they could take the colonies
back in due course - and they tried in 1812. But it
was the confluence of highly improbable events that
led to the birth of the United States and I want to
flesh out how this all transpired.
First, to understand why the Marquis Cornwallis was at
Yorktown one must understand the British strategy in
waging the war. Britain believed the animosity was
mainly limited to New England and that the other
colonies were acting solely out of sympathy to a
brother colony. So they sought to cut New England off
from the other colonies, stop all aid and then crush
the rebels economically. This strategy failed. The British wanted to use the Hudson river to send up warships and thus control any
crossings into New England, but they were never able
to take the powerful fortress at West Point, which
commanded the high ground on both sides of a wicked
bend in the river. They almost took West Point by
subtrefuge thanks to the machinations of one of
Washington's most trusted men, but we'll get to that
later.
The other problem they had was Fort Ticonderoga, on
Lake Champlain. Ticonderoga was called the Gibralter
of the West for no small reason; it was a formidable
fortress that commanded the whole region. It fell
early in the war to the very same man who would later
try to hand over West Point, along with Ethan Allan of
the Green Mountain Boys from Vermont who were each
captaining an expedition to take the fortress. The
British would take it back for a time but lose it
again. Interestingly the first major naval battle of
the war was fought on the Lake in an effort to take -
and defend - Ticonderoga. The British had actually
carried a large warship overland and put it in the
lake and the Americans built a makeshift fleet to
attack. The Americans won.
Two other things plagued the British in their northern
strategy; one was a maddening lethargy that seemed to
settle over every British commander who was sent (at
one point there were THREE of them and all of them
seemed sucked into the black hole of sapped will,
largely because of the comforts of a place much like
home which included willing English women). The other
thing was George Washingto and the Continental Army
ever lurking about, attacking in places of their own
choosing, and moving like ghosts through the land.
As Commanders go Washington was only middling in terms
of military strategy and capabilities. He was actually
the man who started the French and Indian War when he
ordered his scouting party to fire on a party of
Frenchmen who were actually going to Virginia to
negotiate peace. It was the first shot fired in the
war, and Washington never acquitted himself all that
well after that. The British decided no colonials
would serve as officers because of Washington and he
left military service and married a rich widow, thus
acquiring his wife's plantation - Mount Vernon.
But Washington was a man of immense dignity and his
troops loved him despite his being a rather strict
disciplinarian. And Washington could run away like
nobody else. Several times he was cornered and the
British decided to take their time finishing him, only
to find the entire army gone when they finally pressed
the attack. He was the very best at a tacitcal
retreat.
At any rate Washington lost far more battles than he
won, but he kept fighting them. The British had
limited manpower and resources and while Washington's
army was broke and hungry they just kept coming.
In fact, Washington won just a few major battles. He
won Second Bunker Hill decisively and then lost almost
everything until he beat the Hessians at Trenton and
went on to take Princeton. The big victory for the
Americans came not under Washington but under Horation
"granny" Gates, a fusspot commander who wanted to be
in charge of the Continental army. He would have lost,
and in fact ordered a retreat, but a young officer
under his command disobeyed orders to stay out of the
fight, went into battle and turned the Colonial troops
into the fray and won the day. His name is not
mentioned now, not even at Saratoga, but one of the
earliest acts of Congress. Oh, and he was the same man
who took Ticonderoga. Guess his name?
At any rate this young man was shot in the leg and
needed to convalesce so George Washington saw he was
appointed governor of Philadelphia, which the British
had seized for a time. There the young officer met a
young woman named Peggy Shippen, whose father was a
stout loyalist to the British. And while there the
officer was accused of corruption by the state
governor, who was jealous of him. The scandal led
Congress to call for disciplinary action and George
Washington was forced to issue a strong reprimand. The
young officer, who was also owed quite a bit of money
by Congress, never forgage his former benefactor
Washington. When Washington approached him about a new
assignment he was going to essentially make him his
second in command, but the man asked to be put in
charge of West Point instead. Washington gave that to
him. The man immediately made plans to hand over the
formidable stronghold to the British, and lure
Washington into a trap where he would be hanged. By
dumb luck some highwaymen robbed the courrier between
the man and the British and Washington learned of the
treachery. It is illegal to this day to write the name
Benedict Arnold on any official document,and at
Saratoga, where he carried the day, Arnold is just
referred to as "a young officer".
At any rate the British attempt to split New England
off had failed so they went to plan B; the "southern
strategy". Cornwallis was dispateched to the South
where it was believed the public would be more
agreeable and helpful.
But it wasn't so easy; the South is full of swamps or
mountains and guerilla warfare was waged against the
Bloodbacks. Cornwallis authorized a "do whatever is
necessary" policy and some graat atrocities were
committed by the British troops. Any good will on the
part of the locals evaporated.
Still, Cornwallis was a formidable man and would go on
to be the man largely responsible for British control
of Indian later on. His problem was he was going up
against forces he could not hope to fight. I would
argue God Himself was against him.
Washington had dispatched Lafayette to the area to
harrass the British while he attempted to attack New
York City again. (Losing New York had stung his pride
and he was determined to take the city.) Cornwallis
chose the site on the peninsula between the James and
Susquehenna rivers with care, even though it was a
poor place to be situated for Cornwallis as the
peninsula was sandy and swampy and his back was to the
sea. But so what? That worked towards his plan.
It was a trap. He was hoping to lure Washington down
to support the much smaller forces of Lafayette.
The plan was simple; get the whole Continental army
together on the peninsula and then send British
warships up both rivers, cutting off Washington's
avenue of escape. Cornwallis had seen how good
Washington was at retreating and needed him pinned
down. So the gunship would lay down heavy fire and
Washington would be facing the very best forces the
British had, who would move inland and force
Washington to surrender or die.
This all depended on the British navy doing their job
- they didn't.
The fleet was up in Halifax and had they moved when
instructed all would have been lost for the Patriot
cause. But the admiral in charge of the fleet came
down with dysentary and his replacement was a long--
retired old coot who dottered for three days before
departing. The end result was the French forces,
coming up from the West Indiees, arrived first and the
British were trying to attack an entrenched navy. They
lost.
Cornwallis was caught in his own trap. With French
naval guns to his back and on either side and
Washington moving inexorably up the peninsula he was
in an untenable position.
(BTW Washington wanted to leave and attack New York
with so many British soldiers at Yorktown and the
French had to talk him out of it "you're excellency
you have won the war" they had to advise him.)
Day by day Washington moved on towards Cornwallis'
main body and engaged his forces repeatedly. Realizing
the jig was up Cornwallis was forced to surrender.
But he didn't do it. So ashamed at having lost to this
upstart faux general and his ragtag crew of militia
Cornwallis sent an aid with his sword, apologizing tht
the general was ill. Washington refused to accept the
surrender of a junior officer and sent one of his
lowest officers to accept for him. So the batle that
won American independence was settled by two minor
officers.
One condition Washington insisted on was that the
British not play any insulting music as they were
marched out. No Yankee Doodle (which mocked Americans)
or anything else of that stripe was permitted. So they
played a song called "the World Turned Upside-Down"
which indeed it had; the greatest military in the
world, with the greates navy and the one of the
greatest commanders the British had, had surrendered
to a bunch of rude hillbilly colonists.
While the war went on for some time thereafter it was
a foregone conclusion. The British People were sick of
paying for a losing proposition, and Parliament was
soured on it too. King George was furious, of course,
but he was also descending into madness at that point
and nobody was listening to him by then.
And what of Benedict Arnold, the brilliant and
courageous leader who threw it all away? The British
never trusted him, and while they made him a
commissioned officer he never had a decent command. He
moved to London where he died pretty much penniless a
few years later.
And we all know Washington was elected the first
President under the Constitution (there were
"presidents" under the Articles of Confederation too
but that was more like Senate Majority Leader than a
true executive and nobody even remembers their names)
and created so much of the executive branch of our
government. He was a titan, a man among men, who
voluntarily gave up power (in direct opposition to
King George's prediction that Washington would make
himself king).
Washington's strategy, if it WERE a strategy, during
the war was to fight defensively, make the British
move about and pick them off little by little. It was
OUR country, after all, and we knew it better than the
Brits, and there were three million of us to fight
them. It was a sound strategy considering this was the
best army and navy in the world. And it worked.
But also there were so many things that happened that
could have gone another way and ended the war. Had
Arnold's communique not been intercepted by criminals
who happened to be Patriots all would have been lost;
Washington would have been hanged and his lost would
have led to a sense of doom. There were so many other
cases in this; Washington was in the sights of ayoung
Briish soldier who stayed his hand because of the old
custom of not shooting officers. Had he fired it would
all have been over. Washington had several horses shot
from under him and was miraculously never harmed. He
broke up at least one plot against him by his
political rivals. His army survived miraculously,
winning at Trenton in the snow on Christmas day with
most of his troops about to leave his service. Many
were barefoot and it was said the red streak the left
in the snow that day could be seen from all around as
their feet bled. They caught the Hessians drunk and
carousing in their quarters and won handily.
America was truly blessed by God and the fact this
British Admiral got sick at a critical moment is proof
of that claim. If that hadn't happened Cornwallis
would have slaughtered the Continental Army and we
would all be eating Bangers and scones and drinking
tea under the Union flag (it's only called a jack at
sea, I once learned).
So yesterday was a day to remember and to cherish.
Sadly if school children learn of it at all it is no
doubt about how great a disaster it was for native
americans and how horrible it was that we won this
battle.
Hope you enjoyed this. I enjoyed writing it.
Posted by: Timothy Birdnow at
07:55 AM
| No Comments
| Add Comment
Post contains 2329 words, total size 17 kb.
35 queries taking 0.3398 seconds, 182 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.








