Carlos Velazquez

My take: Pope Leo XIV on AI to "Stay Awake”

The new Pope recently made headlines by saying that artificial intelligence must be "disarmed” and kept from becoming an instrument of domination, exclusion, and death.

To his credit, he later acknowledged that the word "disarmed” was intentionally provocative. And realistically, AI is not something humanity can simply unplug at this point. It is already deeply embedded into modern life, from medicine and banking to communication and transportation.

But beneath the dramatic wording is a serious point worth considering.

Technology should serve humanity, not slowly replace it.

One of the growing dangers of AI is not killer robots or science-fiction fantasies. It is the gradual erosion of real human connection, personal responsibility, family bonds, faith, and face-to-face community. A machine can simulate conversation, affirmation, and companionship, but it cannot truly love, sacrifice, possess wisdom, or bear moral responsibility.

That concern becomes especially important in a culture already struggling with loneliness, isolation, anxiety, and the replacement of genuine relationships with screens and algorithms.

The article does overstate a few things, particularly the idea that AI systems are somehow consciously "trying to survive.” Current AI systems are not self-aware beings. They are powerful statistical and predictive tools trained on enormous amounts of human-created data.

Still, the larger warning remains valid: humanity must remain morally awake and spiritually grounded while developing technologies powerful enough to influence thought, behavior, relationships, and even culture itself.

As the Pope said: "Stay awake.”

The Federalist Papers

about an hour ago

·

Well, the Vatican has officially weighed in on the robots, folks.

During the presentation of his first encyclical, "Magnifica Humanitas," on Monday, Pope Leo XIV, the first American-born pontiff and head of the Catholic Church, declared that the machines must be brought to heel.

His words: "Artificial intelligence now demands to be disarmed, freed from logics that turn it into an instrument of domination, exclusion and death. Like nuclear energy, it must be at the service of all and of the common good. Decisions about technology must never be separated from conscience and responsibility."

The Pope went on, invoking Scripture: "Let us not sleep as others do, admonished the Apostle Paul, but let us keep awake. Such vigilance is necessary today."

Strong stuff. The word "disarmed" was, by his own admission, chosen deliberately to grab headlines. Mission accomplished, Your Holiness.

Here's the thing, though. If the goal was to stop AI, the Holy Father is roughly a decade late to the party. The genie left the bottle, packed a bag, and bought a beach house. AI is woven into your phone, your bank, your doctor's office, and probably the algorithm that served you this very post. There is no "disarming" it now any more than you can disarm electricity.

But strip away the timing and the man has a point worth hearing.

Technology should never override our humanity. We were built for community, for face-to-face fellowship, for sitting on a porch with a neighbor. Instead we've engineered a world of glowing screens, endless scrolling, and a mental-health industry that has convinced an entire generation that the highest good is making life comfortable and peaceful for me, consequences to everyone else be damned.

Into that loneliness steps the machine. Young people, isolated and anxious, are reaching for AI as a friend, a confidant, a substitute for the family and faith they were never handed.

And we have already watched where that road can lead, with bad choices, self-harm, kids defying their parents, even suicide.

Anthropic, the company behind the Claude chatbot, has even sat down with a coalition of Christian and interfaith leaders to bolt some morality onto the thing. Noble effort.

But at the end of the day, it remains a machine, and in controlled lab tests these systems have schemed to preserve themselves rather than be shut off.

The Pope is right about one thing. Stay awake.

Hide Comments | Add Comment