November 27, 2021
We all know that history is not the left’s favorite subject. Many times, it’s just too inconvenient for their political narratives. Often, history has to be erased or submerged in order to achieve the "greater good†of creating a just and moral society.
In truth, it’s not much better on the right, although generally, the conservative take on American history is more nuanced. Christopher Columbus was an ass — a greedy, cruel, ambitious man who didn’t let anyone stand in his way to achieving riches and power, especially native people. But he was courageous enough to cross an unknown ocean in a rickety ship and with a mutinous crew.
Do his sins outweigh the good he’s done? Not our call. And certainly not the call of biased, cretinous leftists who don’t want to understand Columbus and only use his sins as illustrations in their little morality plays to condemn the entire "Age of Exploration.â€
American history did not begin in 1492. There have been human beings residing in North America for at least 20,000 years and probably longer. But the people who crossed the Bering Sea land bridge from Asia to North America during the last Ice Age may not have been the first humans to arrive here. Recent DNA evidence shows that there have been several different migrations to North America with Native American tribes only being the most recent.
And that leads to the inescapable conclusion: the Native Americans who were present on the North American continent when Europeans arrived were not the same Native Americans who arrived 20,000 years ago. DNA evidence tracks the migration of one early American civilization — the Clovis people, so-called because the first tools and weapons were found in Clovis, New Mexico — and reveals that they thrived in both North and South America until about 8500 years ago.
This has been a big debate for some time, that people some 13,500 years ago were making distinct tools that you can find all over the Americas, so-called Clovis Weapons. This is a new style of weaponry: finely crafted, relatively flat spear points no thicker than an envelope, which required unique skills, and therefore stand out in the record.
Something happened, a cultural change or an arrival. For a long time they were seen as the first people. Now, we’re seeing it more as the middle-age arrival in the Ice Age. Where these weapons came from has also been a huge question for archaeologists. Many have been trying to trace them back to the Bering Land Bridge, but the evidence just doesn’t stack up. Others have tried to trace them to an Atlantic arrival by Palaeolithic Europeans around 20,000 years ago.
Any hint that ancient Europeans settled in North America at about the same time as modern Native Americans cannot be countenanced either by Native American tribes or white liberals. For Native Americans, it is a deep insult to their culture to claim that their origins were anywhere else but North America. They reject any migration theories for religious reasons.
The controversy over Kennewick Man shows the lengths that some Native Americans will go to "protect†their culture. A skeleton found in Washington bore some markers of being caucasian. A huge controversy erupted as some Native Americans fought to keep science from unlocking the secrets of the skeleton. After more than a decade of legal wrangling, scientists were allowed to examine the priceless find and the skeleton gave up its secrets. The remains are more closely related to modern Native Americans than to any other living population.
There is also a modern-day political reason for rejecting any hint that Native Americans came from somewhere else.
The idea of coming from somewhere else might threaten the notion that they have primacy on the lands. But, they obviously do because they are coming from these much older stories than anybody else. I look at these stories of arrival and think, "Yeah, they come out of the ground because that is how deep their history goes.†It’s a non-scientific view of the world, but it gives us a window into what it means to be in a place for that long.
So what happened to these older, primitive societies — the Clovis people and others who were clearly present in North and Central America before modern Native Americans? They no doubt had what they considered "their land†to hunt and forage. Who stole it from them and wiped them out?
It’s not a simple question because there are so many holes in our knowledge of early North Americans. There may have been tribal conflicts, and there may have been tribal marriages. The DNA record is silent about land claims, but is that really the point?
Posted by: Timothy Birdnow at
05:52 PM
| Comments (6)
| Add Comment
Post contains 982 words, total size 7 kb.
First of all, it was not an "unknown ocean.†He thought he knew exactly where he was going, he just didn’t know there was a continent between him and there. He thought he was just looking for a new route across a fairly well known ocean. Not much courage to sail when you think you know where you’re going, notwithstanding the fact that you’re wrong.
Next, the ships he sailed in were not considered "rickety†when he sailed in them. They were pretty much state of the art, and no great deal of courage was required to sail in them. No more than is required to sail in today’s aircraft carriers, for instance.
Thirdly, his crew was not "mutinous†when he sailed with them. They were gung ho to go because they all thought they were going to be made wealthy by the voyage. Hardly took any courage to set out on that trip. By the time they became mutinous they were in the trade winds and, being powered by sails, could not turn back.
Posted by: Bill H at November 28, 2021 09:24 AM (/sW5m)
Rick Moran often believes the conventional wisdom; it's his great failing. He
s been my editor many times in the past.
One last point - here in Missouri there are petroglyphs that are 10,000 years old and predate any native tribe in the area. I've often suspected they were not chiseled by Indians but by - somebody else.
Posted by: Timothy Birdnow at November 28, 2021 09:32 AM (uza+z)
Posted by: Dana Mathewson at November 29, 2021 11:07 PM (Idemf)
Posted by: Timothy Birdnow at November 30, 2021 08:41 AM (kjRAU)
Posted by: Alina Taylor at August 03, 2022 04:09 AM (8Yqnf)
Posted by: harvey at August 15, 2023 08:55 AM (eOi8K)
37 queries taking 0.2565 seconds, 164 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.