October 23, 2020
I wrote about this a while back. Andrei Piriutko goes into greater detail. It makes one wonder what else has been forgotten throughout our history.
Andrei Piriutko:
The map in question
dates from 1513 and was made by a man named Piri Ibn Haji Memmed,
otherwise known as Piri Re’is. This man was an Admiral in the Turkish
navy, and he made his map from approximately 20 very ancient source
maps, including maps captured from the Portuguese. He claimed the
western portion of the map was obtained from Christopher Columbus. He
also claimed some of the source maps were dated from the time of
Alexander and that some of the others were based upon mathematics.
This map was drawn using the Equidistant projection method. Instead of
using the standard markings of latitude and longitude that are common
on todays maps, the map used the "portolan style†(using a series of
points from which a series of lines radiate outward). One such
mechanism for drawing these maps was the "Eight Wind†system. Others
including the Sixteen Wind system were also used. The reasons for such
drawing methods have long been assumed to benefit the mariner because
these lines seem to correspond to the points of the compass.
It is
interesting to note that other portolan maps that surfaced in the AD
1300’s were highly accurate mariners’ charts of the Mediterranean area,
sometimes including the Black Sea, made by Portuguese, Venetian,
Spanish, Catalan and Arab seamen. They are extremely beautiful maps,
with a high degree of accuracy. How could medieval sailors, with no
navigational aids but the compass, have prepared such accurate charts?
It seems that these highly accurate maps suddenly appeared in Europe
without any evidence of earlier development, and thus, some people
assume that the methods used to make them were developed in a much
earlier time. Interestingly enough, throughout the next several hundred
years these maps did not show any further development. Further to this,
these maps are all drawn from the same scale. This suggests to some,
that the maps were not being developed as a result of mariner survey
activity, and that the lack of variance in scale may suggest that the
understanding of these maps, and the mathematical principles behind
them, was not understood but rather copied from one or several original
maps. The Finnish scholar, Nordenskjold, the leading authority on
portolan maps, claims that all portolanos appear to be based on a
single prototype, that has since vanished. It is assumed that the
source map would have been an ancient Greek map. The problem with this,
is that back in 200 B.C - 100 AD the knowledge of plane geometry and
trigonometry had not been developed in the Greek world. And without
knowledge of geometry and trigonometry, no one could have produced such
accurate maps.
The map is composed of a large number of separate
source maps. Piri Re’is claimed to have used about 20 source maps.
Among them were eight maps of the world done in the time of Alexanders
(400 B.C. to 100 AD), an Arab map of India, four Portuguese maps of the
Indian Ocean and China, and a map drawn by Colombus in the western
region.†He did not, however, say what the other six source maps
were.The resulting map provides remarkably accurate latitude and
longitude locations of coastal features in Africa, North and South
America, and a portion of Antarctica. The source maps must have
utilized the principles of plane geometry and an ability to account for
the curvature of the earths surface. The knowledge of longitude
suggests that the people who drew the maps used a mechanism that was
currently unknown to the west at that time. (This ability to determine
longitude with any degree of accuracy was not known at this time in
Europe, although it may have been known to ancient Arab mariners. The
most interesting thing, is that the map in question is based on an
equidistant projection which has its center on the meridian of
Alexandria in Egypt.
Piri Re’is Map of 1513 contains accurate
mapping of the coastline of the Americas, and amazingly enough, a
portion of Antarctica. (Of course there is significant debate about
whether or not this is actually Antarctica.)
The degree of
accuracy contained in the Piri Re’is map is extraordinary. Given that
the author of this map himself claimed to have based this map, not on
his own surveying skills, but rather on ancient maps, serious questions
about the development of navigation as we currently understand it.
Notice what appears to be Arab dhows sailing in the Atlantic, along the
South American coast, and near Antarctica. An inscription near
Antarctica describes night as "two hours†long,†which certainly does
suggest Antarctic latitudes.
Also notice that the map clearly shows
mountains in the interior of South America, something even the
Portuguese had not discovered by 1513. Some have suggested that the
animals portrayed in the mountains are llamas, even though they appear
to have horns, and amazingly enough, a note says "The gold mines are
endless. Did the map makers know of the gold in Peru?
From this we can assume that Piri Re’is constructed the portion of the map showing Antarctica and South America from ancient Arab maps dating from the time of the Ptolomies, as well as additional information gained from the Portuguese of his day, (Columbus and others), who mapped the northern part of South America as well as islands in the Caribbean.
The question is this: If the southern part of Piri Re’is map of 1513
was based on earlier Arab maps, who were these Arabs who had such
navigational technology to sail there and produce maps? And if the
original Arab maps were based on an equidistant projection which has
its center on the meridian of Alexandria in Egypt, then might this not
have Nabataean implications? If the Nabataeans were already sailing to
Palk Bay in Sri Lanka to obtain Chinese goods, might they not have
sailed farther? If Nabataean entertainers had entered China by 120 -
130 BC then surely they were in a position to sail even farther? It
would only make sense that they would use Alexandria as the center of
their maps, as Alexandria was the center of learning, as well as the
center of Nabataean trade.
Under Ptolemy II, (308 - 246 BC)
Alexandria played a leading role in arts and science. Throughout the
whole Mediterranean world Ptolemy II acquired a reputation for being a
generous patron of poets and scholars. Surrounding himself with a host
of court poets, such as Callimachus and Theocritus, he expanded the
library his father started and financed the Alexandria museum, so that
they became the leading research centers of their day. Learning was not
confined to philosophy and literature but extended also to include
mathematics and natural sciences. The age of Ptolemy II coincided with
the apex of Hellenistic civilization. A prudent and enlightened ruler,
Ptolemy II found his strength in diplomatic ability and his
satisfaction in a very wide scope of learning. Thus it would not be
surprising if Ptolemy II funded an expedition to explore and map the
eastern world. His father had been with Alexander the Great in India,
and so Ptolemy’s curiosity and desire for learning may have led him to
finance exploration journeys to the far ends of the earth. His desire
for learning corresponds with the exact same time when the Nabataeans
supplied the city with many exotic goods from Asia. Thus, it would only
seem that if Ptolemy II financed the exploration, that he would have
used Nabataean sailors to carry it out.
The source maps for Piri
Re’is map might be themselves based on earlier maps, compilations of
which were made at the Great Library of Alexandria (Egypt). However,
there are others who argue that this could not be true, as the
traditional Ptolemaic atlas not only omitted the western hemisphere, it
did not show anything above 63 degrees north or below about 16 degrees
south. There was little reason to do so as long as it was thought that
great heat or cold, or the vastness of the ocean, would prevent anyone
from traveling beyond these bounds.
But supporters of the Nabataean
theory argue that perhaps the Nabataean sailed to Antarctica, and
produced maps and records that were all stored in the Great Library of
Alexandria where they were lost to the world in the fire of 48 BC. They
claim, however, that perhaps one Nabatatean map did survive until 1513,
when it was incorporated into Piri Re’is Map. When challenged about the
scientific knowledge it would take to produce this kind of map (such as
plane geometry and trigonometry) they quote Abu Bakr Ahmad ibn Ali ibn
Qais ibn Wahsiyah an-Nabati, who was a physician and botanist around
900 AD. He was not only a great scholar of his day, but perhaps the
greatest spokesperson on behalf of his illustrious ancestors, the
Nabataeans, to whom he attributed nine-tenths of all scientific
knowledge known. His books are known as Al-Filiaheh an-Nabatiyah (904
AD) and As-Sumum wat-Tiyaqat (900 AD). Ibn Wahsiyah claimed that his
ancestors, the Nabataeans, were held in low regard by the Arabs of his
day, when in fact they were the ones who brought to the Arabs knowledge
of mathematics, astronomy, animal husbandry and more. Then to top it
off, they point to an acticle in Scientific American, (1900) where
archeologists discovered an astoundingly advanced gearing system in a
Greek navigational instrument that dated back to 65 B.C. Sadly, this
discover was noted, written up, and then filed away and is seldom
referred to today by historians.
Unfortunately, none of the
very early maps from the classical world, have survived. The maps
accompanying Ptolemy’s great work on geography, for example, were
totally lost and the maps that are included in his later published
books were drawn 1,000 years after he wrote. An early Arab author,
moreover, reported that a globe of the world by Ptolemy (the
geographer) existed in Cairo in the 14th century. Arabic literature
also contains numerous tantalizing mentions of "lost maps.†The 10th
century author Ibn Nadim, for example, speaks of a Persian map of the
world drawn on silk in colored paints, conceivably a copy of a
classical map, but in any case lost to history. But perhaps some day,
an early map will be discovered. In 1955, a cartographer named M.
Destombes announced the discovery of Ferdinand Magellan’s own chart of
his epochal circumnavigatio
So...
Did the Nabataeans reach Antarctica and South America?
Posted by: Timothy Birdnow at
07:59 AM
| Comments (5)
| Add Comment
Post contains 1804 words, total size 11 kb.
Posted by: Dana Mathewson at October 23, 2020 10:15 AM (6Btpe)
I'd like to get a map too. I may have posted one when I posted about this in the past, but I can't find it.
Posted by: Timothy Birdnow at October 24, 2020 08:02 AM (b1yQi)
Posted by: Dana Mathewson at October 24, 2020 02:58 PM (cIZUu)
Posted by: Timothy Birdnow at October 25, 2020 07:54 AM (Wolb4)
Our Shop is one of the best shops to buy weed online UK and to buy cannabis online UK without a medical card. We have quality top shelf strains of weed for sale UK. We offer free delivery across the UK and Europe and we do ship worldwide We have more than 90 different strains. aquatic weed cutter for sale uk. how to buy weed online. Darknetweedstore.com Do not hesitate to visit our website below if you are looking for weed for sale UK, Europe, and the USA, Weed for sale Ireland, weed for sale USA, Mail order weed the UK, Buy weed Europe. , order weed online uk
PROMT Deliveries
https://darknetweedstore.com/
Buy Cannabis online, you can order Weed & Cannabis Online in the UK. We deliver fast using next Day Delivery. Get Cannabis & Weed for sale in UK Weed Supermarket. Buy Cannabis online UK, Mail order Weed UK Buy weed online UK Buy marijuanna Online UK. We deliver fast using Next Day Delivery. Weed for sale in UK. aquatic weed cutter for sale uk. how to buy weed online.
Posted by: buy weed online uk at October 26, 2020 05:42 PM (hJ4N+)
37 queries taking 0.5542 seconds, 172 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.