September 25, 2020

Pouring on the Gasoline

Dana Mathewson

Steven Hayward, whom we are used to reading at Power Line, writes this excellent article at City Journal.

It’s a commonplace that America is more divided than at any time since the 1850s, which ended with the country hurtling toward civil war. The oddity of our Civil War, which resembled conventional warfare in that the two sides fielded uniformed rather than guerilla armies and fought within a distinct territorial divide, is that it distracts us from the fact that civil war is the most typical political phenomenon in human history. Count it as another example of American exceptionalism, perhaps. Except that today the air is thick with talk that we might actually have another one.

Max Weber was merely the most explicit in a long line of political thinkers with his succinct reminder that "The decisive means for politics is violence.” It is the unique achievement of constitutional democracy to substitute ballots for bullets, but the experience of a peaceful transition of power from a losing party to a winning party is barely 200 years old—dating back to 1800, to be precise. That’s not even the day before yesterday, in the long human story. And as we saw, it lasted only 60 years until one party, southern Democrats, refused to accept the results of a free election and decided to revert to bullets. I have long tried to explain to students and fellow citizens alike that we take America’s political stability since the Civil War too much for granted. In my experience, it has been foreign students who comprehend this complacency, while native students tend to yawn and look at their smartphones.

[...]

The prospect of electoral chaos was elevated by the war-gaming exercise of the Transition Integrity Project, in which a disputed election might feature riots, states threatening secession, a stubborn Trump abusing his powers to remain in office, and the military wondering who they should report to at noon next January 20. Needless to say it made for sensational copy in the media, much of which was both overblown and underblown: overblown because of the frothy Seven Days in May specter it suggested, and underblown in that it barely scratched the surface of more realistic permutations of what could go wrong with this election.

As it happens, I know one of the two organizers of TIP, Nils Gilman, the vice president of programs at the Berggruen Institute. Gilman is one of the first persons I got to know when I came to UC Berkeley four years ago. He worked in the chancellor’s office, coping with the aftermath of the Milo Yiannopoulos riot of February 2017, which I witnessed. A historian by academic background, he believes in all the wrong things, such as abolishing the electoral college and the Senate, expanding the Supreme Court, and admitting Puerto Rico and D.C. as states, for starters. He likes some truly wild-eyed schemes for global-level taxation. In other words, he holds what increasingly have become the mainstream views of the Democratic Party today. In other areas, he’s quirky. Gilman says things about our monied elites that sound like Tucker Carlson. He thinks the only thing worse than conservative indifference or hostility to climate-change action would be conservative embrace of solving climate change, because it would involve "avocado politics”—"green on the outside, brown on the inside.” We’ve had a lot of vigorous but cordial arguments about these and many other things.

So it came as a shock to me that, on the brink of a possible constitutional crisis and with cities already on fire, Gilman decided to pour on more gasoline. In a now notorious tweet about Michael Anton, author of the famous "Flight 93 Election” essay of 2016 and sometime writer for City Journal, Gilman wrote: "Michael Anton is the Robert Brasillach of our times and deserves the same fate.” Who? Robert Brasillach was a collaborationist writer in the Vichy regime in France. He was executed by firing squad after the liberation for his "intellectual crimes.”

Gilman now insists that despite the clearly written words "deserves the same fate,” he did not mean literally that Anton should be executed. But if Sarah Palin can be accused, as she was by the New York Times editorial page (libel suit still pending), of inciting the shooting of Representative Gabby Giffords in 2011, though it was clear within hours that the shooter was a mentally ill individual, you’d think that saying something like "deserves the same fate” as an executed Nazi collaborator would rise to the same standard. We also have in the background the literal example of James Hodgkinson, who was politically motivated in his attempt to kill Republican House members in 2017.

[...]

Gilman is not alone, however, in language that goes over the line of late. Charlie Sykes, an anti-Trump conservative, this week tweeted, "For no particular reason, this morning I’ve been thinking about Nicolae Ceaușescu’s last public appearance.” The Romanian dictator’s last public appearance, of course, was the execution of him and his wife following a ten-minute trial. This is not just unsubtle; it isn’t even artful.

There is a broader point here that isn’t about pining for a bygone era of "civility” in politics. There was no such era. Just check the campaign rhetoric of the election of 1800. Liberals today like to label and deplore "othering.” This is often overdone, but it sends me back to something my (and Anton’s) teacher Harry Jaffa wrote more than 40 years ago: "Those who see each other as utterly alien cannot be fellow citizens.” But that’s where we are right now, with large numbers of Americans utterly alienated from many of their fellow citizens. The causes and responsibility for this can be debated another day. Jaffa added: "In a republic, the sobriety of the citizens replaces the force of authority as the principal source of order.” If we do have a train-wreck election, it will be the sobriety of Americans that saves us. Singling out individuals by name and suggesting, even by strained analogy, that they deserve the equivalent fate of a Nazi propagandist (or a Romanian dictator) does not promote that virtue.

I've left out just enough, I hope, to whet your appetite for the entire article, which is to be found here: https://www.city-journal.org/pouring-on-the-gasoline

Posted by: Timothy Birdnow at 02:53 PM | Comments (2) | Add Comment
Post contains 1047 words, total size 7 kb.

1 I agree; this is leading to what will wind up being an American Reign of Terror. We're going to have a real civil war. We have the guns, the food, control of the countryside, but they have the determination. It'll be horrible.

Posted by: Timothy Birdnow at September 26, 2020 07:26 AM (ItMSC)

2

Buy cannabis UK, Mail order Weed UK Buy weed online UK Buy marijuana Online UK. We deliver fast using Next Day Delivery. Weed for sale in the UK. Buy weed online Uk! Uk & US mail order Legal weed online store, offering a variety of best weed strains, Edibles, weed wax & oil, THC and Cbd oil for sale. Buy legit marijuana and weed online, Legit weed online from the USA, Buy original weed online, Buy legit cannabis online, Buy legit cartridge vape pen online, Buy weed online, Buy Marijuana online, a Best marijuana shop in the USA, Buy weed online UK, Buy weed in Europe, Buy Cannabis Marijuana Weed Online.


We provide different strains all being top-shelf grade AA+ the strongest and this makes it easy for you to choose which strain goes well with you so buy cannabis online with confidence. Keep away from minors and Smoke with Joy We ship to all 50 States, the UK, and Worldwide. 1 Ounce =30 Grams and an LB = 480 Grams. Order weed the online UK.

https://darknetweedstore.com


Posted by: buy weed uk at September 30, 2020 05:30 PM (LGTz1)

Hide Comments | Add Comment




What colour is a green orange?




27kb generated in CPU 0.01, elapsed 0.0495 seconds.
43 queries taking 0.0367 seconds, 136 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.
Always on Watch
The American Thinker
Bird`s Articles
Old Birdblog
Birdblog`s Literary Corner
Behind the Black
Canada Free Press
Common Sense and Wonder < br/ > Christian Daily Reporter
Citizens Free Press
Climatescepticsparty,,a>
_+
Daren Jonescu
Dana and Martha Music On my Mind Conservative Victory
Eco-Imperialism
Gelbspan Files Infidel Bloggers Alliance
Let the Truth be Told
Newsmax
>Numbers Watch
OANN
The Reform Club
Revolver
FTP Student Action
Veritas PAC
FunMurphys
The Galileo Movement
Intellectual Conservative
br /> Liberty Unboound
One Jerusalem
Powerline
Publius Forum
Ready Rants
The Gateway Pundit
The Jeffersonian Ideal
Thinking Democrat
Ultima Thule
Young Craig Music
Contact Tim at bgocciaatoutlook.com

Monthly Traffic

  • Pages: 1417
  • Files: 270
  • Bytes: 42.1M
  • CPU Time: 3:24
  • Queries: 67752

Content

  • Posts: 24254
  • Comments: 98715

Feeds


RSS 2.0 Atom 1.0