Obama's Discipline Quotas
Dana Mathewson
An
excellent article from Power Line, with great reporting by Minnesota's Katherine Kersten, one of America's great investigative reporters"
In 2014, the Obama administration promulgated a
"guidanceâ€to America’s public schools that threatened federal investigations and
litigation against schools where black students are disciplined (
e.g., by suspension) more often, on a
pro rata basis,
than white students, on the ground that such numerical discrepancy is
evidence of discrimination. Many schools responded by adopting
discipline quotas, which meant in practice that after a certain number
of students of a particular race had been suspended, teachers and
administrators were helpless to enforce any kind of discipline in
classrooms.
The Obama
administration is gone, thankfully, but its "guidance†has not been
revoked. Meanwhile, state governments and federal courts that are in
liberal hands have taken up the claim that disparate incidence of
discipline must be discriminatory, a theory that flies in the face of
common observation that misbehavior in school is not randomly
distributed in the student population.
In Minnesota, the
Department of Human Rights has reportedly sent letters to 43 school
districts and charter schools, telling them that they are under
investigation because of racial disparities in discipline. There is an
added Orwellian element in that news of the letters has leaked out, but
no one knows what 43 school districts have gotten the letters, or what
the letters say. Under Minnesota law, it apparently is difficult if not
impossible for the public to get that information. So the far-left
administration of trust fund billionaire Mark Dayton is able to bully
school districts in the shadows, without public knowledge or recourse.
Brace yourself,
parents of Minnesota. Here’s what’s coming soon to a school near you:
increased violence, brazen challenges to teachers’ authority and a
chaotic environment where learning is an uphill battle. Teachers who
try to exert control will find their hands tied, and some kids — no
longer accountable for their behavior — will feel free to provoke
mischief and mayhem.
If this happens at
your school, you’ll be able to thank the Minnesota Department of Human
Rights (MDHR). In fall 2017, the department sent letters to 43 school
districts and charter schools across the state, announcing that the
schools are under investigation because their student discipline
records suggest that black and Native American students are disciplined
at a rate that exceeds their proportion of the student population.
***
Here, in essence, is MDHR’s position: The primary cause of racial
discipline gaps in schools is racist teachers and discipline policies,
not differing rates of student misconduct. Schools must move to end
these statistical group disparities. If administrators don’t agree to
change their practices in ways that reduce black and Native American
discipline rates, according to MinnPost, "[Human Rights Commissioner
Kevin] Lindsey says the state will initiate litigation.â€
We’ve seen this
movie before, most recently in the St. Paul Public Schools. There, it
had devastating consequences for students of all backgrounds. MDHR
bureaucrats must have been the only people in St. Paul who weren’t
paying attention to this debacle.
Posted by: Timothy Birdnow at
06:54 AM
| No Comments
| Add Comment
Post contains 530 words, total size 6 kb.
23kb generated in CPU 0.0089, elapsed 0.4562 seconds.
35 queries taking 0.4506 seconds, 157 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.