"Clinesmith, who worked on both the FBI’s Hillary Clinton email investigation and on the Trump-Russia collusion inquiry, pleaded guilty to falsifying a document during the bureau’s efforts to renew FISA authority to wiretap Carter Page, who was an adviser to Trump's 2016 campaign.

Newly-declassified details about Clinesmith’s involvement include a wide swath of information about his role in the case. He was a key go-to for former FBI lawyer Lisa Page and fired FBI special agent Peter Strzok throughout the debunked collusion saga and a main driver in obtaining a FISA warrant against Page based on the infamous Steele dossier.

Clinesmith also granted his seal of approval on a document describing the FBI’s pretextual briefing of then-candidate Trump, was deeply involved in the investigation into retired Lt. Gen. Mike Flynn, played a role in going after former Trump campaign adviser George Papadopoulos, and more. He also helped the FBI push its "Cross Wind” investigation, which Just the News can confirm related to the targeting of security expert Walid Phares, which resulted in no accusations of wrongdoing and no charges.
Knee-deep in the mud

Clinesmith confessed in August 2020 that he had manipulated a CIA email in 2017 to state that Carter Page was "not a source” for the CIA when that agency had actually told the bureau on multiple occasions that Page was in fact an "operational contact” for the CIA.

Boasberg, the federal judge who is blocking Trump’s efforts to deport Venezuelan gang members, also played a key and controversial role in the aftermath of the Trump-Russia collusion saga as the leader of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court. The judge, nominated to the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia by then-President Barack Obama in 2011, is currently engaged in an all-out legal battle with the Trump Justice Department.

But in his role as the head of the FISA Court he made a number of divisive decisions, including a slap on the wrist for a member of the FBI’s Crossfire Hurricane team, the appointment of officials who had defended the FBI’s actions during the Russiagate saga, the renewal of the FBI’s FISA powers, and more.
Boasberg defends Clinesmith

Boasberg ruled this week that "probable cause exists” to hold Trump administration officials in criminal contempt after they violated his orders by continuing deportation flights. But his ruling follows the Supreme Court holding that Boasberg's court was in an improper venuefor the case altogether.

Boasberg, in his role as a federal judge, denied the Justice Department’s efforts to seek up to six months behind bars for Clinesmith, who pleaded guilty in Special Counsel John Durham’s Trump-Russia investigation — instead giving Clinesmith a year of probation, 400 hours of community service, and no fine.

Durham argued that Clinesmith’s "deceptive conduct” related to the FISA application fabrication "was antithetical to the duty of candor and eroded the FISA’s confidence in the accuracy of all previous FISA applications worked on by the defendant,” and said his deception "fueled public distrust of the FBI and of the entire FISA program itself.”

But Boasberg seemed to defend Clinesmith’s deceptive FISA-related actions during his January 2021 sentencing.

"Mr. Clinesmith likely believed that what he said was true," Boasberg wrote, adding, "I do not believe he was attempting to achieve an end he knew was wrong." The judge claimed that "it is not clear to me that the fourth FISA warrant would not have been signed but for this error. … Even if Mr. Clinesmith had been accurate about Mr. Page’s relationship with the other government agency, the warrant may well have been signed and the surveillance authorized."

Durham had argued that Clinesmith's deception "fueled public distrust of the FBI and of the entire FISA program itself.” Anthony Scarpelli, then a top prosecutor on Durham’s team, also argued that "the defendant’s criminal conduct tarnished the integrity of the FISA program” and that "the resulting harm is immeasurable.”

Clinesmith told the court that "I am deeply remorseful for any effect my actions may have had” on the FISA process even as he claimed that "I never intended to mislead my colleagues about the status of Dr. Page.”

But Boasberg lamented that Clinesmith had been "abused” and "vilified” on a "national scale” when the judge handed down his sentence, though he did acknowledge that the FISA court’s reputation "has suffered” from the ex-FBI attorney’s actions.

Posted by: Dana Mathewson at April 18, 2025 10:28 PM (QSsdw)

Hide Comments | Add Comment