June 25, 2018

Antarctic Land Rising while Global Warming Shrinks

Timothy Birdnow

Reuters tries to explain the lack of acceleration of sea level rise by claiming that the land is rising as a result of declining ice weight and thus keeping sea levels relatively constant.

According to the article:
The Earth’s crust in West Antarctica is rising by up to 4.1 centimetres (1.61 inches) a year, an international team wrote in the journal Science, in a continental-scale version of a foam mattress reforming after someone sitting on it gets up.

The rate, among the fastest ever recorded, is likely to accelerate and could total 8 metres (26.25 feet) this century, they said, helping to stabilise the ice and brake a rise in sea levels that threatens coasts from Bangladesh to Florida.

"It’s good news for Antarctica,” lead author Valentina Barletta of the Technical University of Denmark and Ohio State University told Reuters of the findings, based on GPS sensors placed on bedrock around the Amundsen Sea in West Antarctica."

End excerpt.

See, sea levels aren't cooperating, so they had to find a way to explain this and not discard their apocalyptic scenario.

The authors of this article either do not understand how this works or they don't care to report the reality of the situation.

The Earth's crust is like a tube of toothpaste that is half full. Weight from ice or water puts pressure on the crust, and the result is that where land is low it is higher in places with less weight on it. If you squeeze a tube of toothpaste in one spot it rises in another, right? Magma under the crust shifts and you have rising land - and falling land.

Which means that somewhere the land MUST be dropping. In the end you have homeostasis because rising antarctic land means shrinking land elsewhere, probably in ocean depths.

But there is no evidence of land actually dropping anywhere.

This article fails to mention a number of things. For instance, West Antarctica has been losing ice precisly because there is considerable volcanic activity under the ice sheet, which is largley responsible for the melting sheet and for the large ice shelf collapses. This also helps explain the land rise to a degree, as there is considerable pressure underneath the land that is pushing upward. It should also be pointed out that the East Antarctic ice sheet has been gaining mass as WAIS has been losing it - more so in fact. (In point of fact, overall Antarctica has been greater than the ice loss.

What does that mean? It means there is increased isostatic pressure in the East while vulcanism is reducing the weight of ice in the West. Naturally there will be a rise in the west.

Here's a real doozie from the Reuters article:

"The fast rise of the bedrock beneath will lift ever more of the ice onto land, reducing the risks of a breakup of the sheet caused by warming ocean water seeping beneath the ice."

End excerpt.

I don't think so.

The West Antarctic ice Sheet is different from the East, in that it is not an ice dome so much as a long glacier that stretches out miles into the ocean. Water is ALREADY UNDER IT and even where it is not the fact is the ice is moving because of warming from volcanoes on the underside, which means that as the land rises the ice feels more pressure from the interior of the continent and thus more ice will slide into the ocean - and the ocean ice will break up faster. It's like tipping over a glass of water; the more you tip the glass the more water will flow out of it.

The fact is this is nothing new or unusual, and the dishonesty in not discussing the eastern part of the continent, or the volcanic activity under the WAIS, speaks volumes. This is more fake news/fake science.

Oh, and did I mention there hasn't been any planetary warming since the late '90's? Strange how no warming can melt ice.

A recent paper in Nature argued that Antarctica has claims Antarctica has seen a tripling of ice loss in the last five years although this is entirely based on WAIS ice loss.  (Needless to say the mainstream media has breathlessly reported this, without the caveat.) What is ignored in this paper is a competing paper by James Zwally et. al that shows that the Eastern ice sheet has more than made up for the loss of ice in the west.

David Whitehouse at the Global Warming Policy Foundation discrediting the paper in Nature, by the way.

Whitehouse states:

"The main loss of ice is from west Antarctica which is the largest and densest volcanic region on Earth with over 100 volcanoes under the ice.

The first worrying thing about the paper are the error bars. In scientific literature it is normal to use errors of two standard deviations and not one. Even two sigma errors are in my opinion not enough but one certainly isn’t. It’s often used in cases where to quote two sigma errors would make the measurement look unconvincing.

The paper states that 2720 +/- 1390 billion tonnes of ice were lost between 1992 -2017. Using two sigma errors changes that to a loss of 2720 +/- 2780 billion tonnes, which gives an entirely different impression. In fact the hypothesis that there has been any ice loss at all is not warranted by such errors.:

end excerpt.

Another point to ponder; the WAIS has shrunk far more in cooler weather in the past.
According to this article in National Geographic:

"Scientists have discovered that the West Antarctic Ice Sheet underwent a major retreat between 10,000 and 12,000 years ago, at a time when the world was actually cooler than it is today. The collapse happened at the close of the last Ice Age, and it left the ice sheet 135,000 square miles smaller than it is today – a difference nearly as large as the state of Montana.


"Most researchers had believed that the West Antarctic ice sheet hadn’t been much smaller than it is now for at least 120,000 years. "We were really surprised,” says Reed Scherer, of Northern Illinois University in DeKalb, who co-authored the new paper, published today in the journal Nature, with nine other scientists."

End excerpt

As I have pointed out before, much of the WAIS floats on top of water. If the ice sheet is breaking up, it means warer water is underneath the ice. But why?  If ice is forming heavily on the surface of the ocean it means the air is not warmer, but rather the water underneath. Now the Antarctic is surrounded by a circumpolar current of cold water that is very wide and deep - and it is unlikely that warm water would find it's way through that current. warm water sits on top of cold water, after all. So the warming water is coming from the continent itself.  That tells me it is because of volcanic activity, not warming air.

Bear in mind, the average coastal temperature is
14* F. amd evem the warmer Antarctic Peninsula is below the freezing point of water in mid summer most of the time. Ice melt could hardly be related to the temperature.

This was another good college try but in the end it fails.

Posted by: Timothy Birdnow at 10:41 AM | Comments (14) | Add Comment
Post contains 1235 words, total size 9 kb.

1 Every content written in your article is fabulous thanks for the sharing this free windows dvd player my advice you use the dvd player and watching for video in full hd. 

Posted by: Addu at January 28, 2019 11:09 PM (xNR+h)

2 The content of your blog is very amazing and you will get something about this kind of topic, I might say this is an effective way of sharing your knowledge to everyone! Thanks for sharing your article. 
click here

Posted by: Daniel Perez at May 21, 2019 07:41 AM (4xnZ1)

3 It is a nice post and i like it. You explained in a nice way. Regularly  i will follow your blog. The articles you shared are very nice. Keep sharing the useful posts like this only.

Posted by: best photo editor for android at June 10, 2019 03:34 AM (OqL9o)

4 Quality posts is the key to be a focus for the users to pay a visit the great work. jailbreak firestick  https://bestchinchillacage.com/

Posted by: firestickjailbreak.net at October 31, 2019 02:50 AM (qvTIB)

5 On the topic of internet page potty racers you will see my best information, be sure to take a look at this level of detail.

Posted by: ariana at December 09, 2019 10:10 PM (CwvEP)

6 I appreciate your hard work. Keep posting new updates with us. This is really a wonderful post. Nice Blog Very interesting and useful information on your website. Thanks for sharing the blog and this great information which is definitely going to help us. office.com/setup office.com/setup

Posted by: office.com/setup at May 02, 2020 02:49 AM (UMxUZ)

7 Right. Your views are right and very helpful. To bring ease in life shop and save near me can help and simplify your life. Here you will get what you need .

Posted by: John at November 17, 2020 04:13 AM (le/fq)

8 Your blog is very helpful and interesting. To make your life simple and easy, it is important that you visit the shop and save near me

Posted by: John at November 17, 2020 04:23 AM (le/fq)

9 Your blog is very interesting and informative. You can bring ease by visiting a shop and save near me. It is very helpful.

Posted by: John at November 17, 2020 04:26 AM (le/fq)

10 Gosaveshop is one of cheapest online shopping site in USA , Where you can get hundreds of gift vouchers and unlimited offers for the new and old buyers and every one have the question from where to get high quality products online.

Posted by: Ali zafar at November 17, 2020 09:06 AM (0Ijr6)

11 What an excellent article. Thanks for writing it. Shopping for home is convenient for floors.                                                                                  hardwood floor refinishing in providence

Posted by: Ken Jones at April 27, 2021 01:56 PM (D3A0L)

12 Thanks for the detailed article on this topic. I would like to see more such awesome articles from you. Also you can get the new and best features of FMWhatsapp which are coming in 2022-

FMWhatsapp APK

Posted by: FMWhatsapp APK at December 10, 2021 01:03 AM (xGFhg)

13 Yes, thank you Peter. You are loved. Tim - The Carpet Installer

Posted by: Tim at January 10, 2022 04:05 PM (FKKPe)

14 Welcome to our website of escort service in Aerocity. Here we provide all types of escorts girl in Aerocity. Like Indian, Russian, collage girl, bangladeshi girl. Since we are here famous for providing important moments in the life of the customer. Many agency are claiming that they are best for escort service in aerocity.

Jareena Delhi Escort Service is one of the most popular Escort Service in Delhi that operates in virtually whole Delhi NCR. Many old clients of ours come to Delhi for business and want a sexy escort who indulges in all kind of sex positions and our Escort Service in Delhi are capable to supply them exactly what they dreams. Read More:- 
We provide you the Call Girl In Connaught Place at very affordable price. Nights are not to sleep in bed, but to express love together with your partner. But what if your partner is far away from you. Read More:- 

Posted by: Jareena at February 20, 2022 12:54 AM (cTzWE)

Hide Comments | Add Comment

What colour is a green orange?

34kb generated in CPU 0.03, elapsed 0.0637 seconds.
43 queries taking 0.041 seconds, 149 records returned.
Powered by Minx 1.1.6c-pink.
Always on Watch
The American Thinker
Bird`s Articles
Old Birdblog
Birdblog`s Literary Corner
Behind the Black
Canada Free Press
Common Sense and Wonder < br/ > Christian Daily Reporter
Citizens Free Press
Daren Jonescu
Dana and Martha Music On my Mind Conservative Victory
Gelbspan Files Infidel Bloggers Alliance
Let the Truth be Told
>Numbers Watch
The Reform Club
FTP Student Action
Veritas PAC
The Galileo Movement
Intellectual Conservative
br /> Liberty Unboound
One Jerusalem
Publius Forum
Ready Rants
The Gateway Pundit
The Jeffersonian Ideal
Thinking Democrat
Ultima Thule
Young Craig Music
Contact Tim at bgocciaatoutlook.com

Monthly Traffic

  • Pages: 1417
  • Files: 270
  • Bytes: 42.1M
  • CPU Time: 3:24
  • Queries: 67752


  • Posts: 24494
  • Comments: 102203


RSS 2.0 Atom 1.0